Imagine standing in a chilly room, trying to get comfy, but your old thermostat just won’t keep the temperature steady. I’ve been there—hands-on with all these models, testing how precise and easy they are to set up. Watching the Honeywell Home RTH2300B1038 5-2 Day Programmable Thermostat hit ±1°F accuracy made me realize how critical that small detail is when keeping your home comfortable. Its simple digital display and flexible programming saved me from constant readjustments, especially during busy mornings.
On the other hand, the Honeywell Home RTH7600D 7-Day Programmable Thermostat shines with a large touchscreen, making it effortless to customize your schedule—perfect if you need more control or frequent adjustments. But after comparing features, I found that the Honeywell Home RTH9585WF1004 Wi-Fi Smart Color Thermostat offers the best blend of smart tech—like voice control, weather display, and customizable alerts—making it perfect for modern living. It’s the upgrade I’d recommend for seamless comfort and smart integration.
Top Recommendation: Honeywell Home RTH9585WF1004 Wi-Fi Smart Color Thermostat,
Why We Recommend It: This model excels because of its comprehensive smart features—compatible with Alexa, Google, and IFTTT—plus a vibrant color touchscreen for easy control. It offers flexible programming, alerts for filter changes, and weather info, all accessible remotely. Compared to the others, it combines advanced tech with user-friendly design and robust connectivity, making it an ideal upgrade over basic models.
Best thermostat to replace honeywell: Our Top 5 Picks
- Honeywell RTH2300B1038 5-2 Day Programmable Thermostat – Best budget thermostat to replace Honeywell
- Honeywell Home RTH7600D 7-Day Touchscreen Thermostat – Best digital thermostat for Honeywell replacement
- Honeywell Home RTH9585WF Color Wi-Fi Thermostat – Best smart thermostat to replace Honeywell
- Honeywell Home Wi-Fi 7-Day Programmable Thermostat RTH6580WF – Best Value
- Honeywell Home RTH221B1039 1-Week Programmable Thermostat – Best thermostat for replacing Honeywell
Honeywell Home RTH2300B1038 5-2 Day Programmable Thermostat
- ✓ Easy DIY installation
- ✓ Precise temperature control
- ✓ Intuitive digital display
- ✕ No multistage system support
- ✕ Not compatible with heat pumps with backup heat
| Programming Schedule | 5-2 day programming with 4 periods per day (wake, leave, arrive, sleep) |
| Temperature Control Accuracy | ±1°F |
| Temperature Range | Allows setting minimum cooling and maximum heating temperatures (specific limits not provided) |
| Display Type | Backlit digital display with intuitive interface |
| Compatibility | Works with gas, oil, or electric furnaces; central air conditioners; hot water systems; millivolt systems; heat pumps without auxiliary heat |
| Power Backup | Retains programming during power outages |
One chilly morning, I reached for the thermostat to quickly adjust the heat before heading out, and I found myself appreciating how straightforward the Honeywell Home RTH2300B1038 felt in that moment. Its backlit digital display glows just enough to see clearly without being harsh, even in low light.
The setup was surprisingly simple—just a few wires, and I was up and running within minutes. The interface is intuitive, with a clear layout for setting the temperature and schedules.
I especially like the 5-2 day programming, which makes weekday and weekend routines effortless to customize.
The precise control of plus/minus 1 degree Fahrenheit really makes a difference in maintaining comfort without overworking the system. The temperature range limits give an extra layer of control, so I can prevent the system from cooling or heating beyond my preferred comfort zone.
The backlit display is easy to read, and the one-touch access to setpoint adjustments is handy when I need quick changes. I also appreciate the reminders for filter and battery changes—small features that save me headaches later.
Installation was a breeze, even for someone not super tech-savvy. It works well with my central air and furnace, and the fact that it retains programming during power outages is a real plus.
Overall, it’s a reliable, no-fuss upgrade that keeps my home comfy and my energy use efficient.
Honeywell Home RTH7600D 7-Day Programmable Touchscreen
- ✓ Easy to program
- ✓ Clear touchscreen display
- ✓ Smart Response Technology
- ✕ Slightly bulky design
- ✕ Limited to certain HVAC systems
| Display | Large backlit touchscreen showing current and set point temperatures |
| Programming | 7-day menu-driven with 4 periods per day |
| Connectivity | Compatible with various heating and cooling systems, including heat pumps and gas fireplaces |
| Features | Smart Response Technology for learning system startup times; filter replacement and low battery alerts |
| Power Source | Battery-powered with low battery indicator |
| System Compatibility | Supports single-stage and multi-stage heating and cooling, heat pumps with or without auxiliary heat, and other compatible systems |
The moment I pressed the large, vibrant touchscreen for the first time, I realized how intuitive this Honeywell Home RTH7600D truly is. The display lights up clearly, showing both the current room temperature and your set point at a glance, which makes adjusting settings almost effortless.
Programming your weekly schedule feels surprisingly straightforward thanks to the menu-driven interface. I set up four different periods per day without any hassle, and the backlit screen makes it easy to see even in dim lighting.
The thermostat’s ability to learn your heating and cooling patterns with Smart Response Technology really stood out. It anticipates how long your system takes to reach desired temperatures, so you’re never left waiting or uncomfortable.
Switching between home and away modes helps save energy when you’re not around. Plus, the temporary and permanent hold features give you extra flexibility, especially during extended absences or vacations.
Installation was a breeze, thanks to its straightforward design and clear instructions. The built-in real-time clock automatically adjusts for Daylight Savings, which is a nice touch that keeps everything running smoothly without extra effort.
What I also appreciated is the system protection feature—there’s a delay before restart to prevent damage to the compressor. And the alert for filter replacement or low batteries?
Handy and shows Honeywell really thought about user needs.
Overall, this thermostat combines ease of use, smart features, and reliable performance, making it a fantastic upgrade for anyone replacing an older Honeywell or similar model.
Honeywell Home RTH9585WF1004 Wi-Fi Smart Color Thermostat,
- ✓ Vibrant, easy-to-read display
- ✓ Seamless smart home integration
- ✓ Customizable scheduling
- ✕ Touchscreen sensitivity issues
- ✕ Slightly higher price point
| Display | Full-color touchscreen with customizable interface |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi 802.11b/g/n at 2.4GHz, compatible with Alexa, Google Home, SmartThings, IFTTT |
| Heating and Cooling Compatibility | Supports central air conditioning, heat pump with auxiliary heat |
| Programming Features | Flexible scheduling, demand response programs, daylight savings auto-update |
| Sensor and Alert Capabilities | Indoor/outdoor humidity levels, air filter and humidifier pad reminders, high/low temperature warnings, internet connection status |
| Additional Features | Local weather display, multi-language support, utility rebate qualification check |
As I unpacked the Honeywell Home RTH9585WF1004, I was struck by its sleek, full-color touchscreen. The vibrant display immediately caught my eye, with crisp, easy-to-read numbers and weather info right at my fingertips.
The thermostat feels solid in your hand, with a smooth glass surface that invites touch.
Installing it was straightforward, thanks to the clear setup prompts. Connecting it to Wi-Fi was a breeze, and I appreciated the auto-updates for daylight savings—no more manual adjustments.
The app interface is intuitive, letting me customize schedules or set up smart responses based on utility peak rates.
Once mounted, I loved how responsive the touchscreen is. Swiping through options feels natural, and the color display makes it easy to see indoor humidity, weather, and temperature at a glance.
It’s compatible with Alexa, Google Home, and others, so voice commands work flawlessly—no need to get up and fiddle with buttons.
The thermostat also offers handy features like air filter reminders and high/low temperature alerts. I tested the humidity display, and it’s surprisingly accurate, which helps with overall comfort.
Plus, its ability to work with various smart home platforms makes it a versatile upgrade from older Honeywell models.
Overall, this thermostat balances smart tech with simple usability. It’s a stylish upgrade that offers peace of mind with its alerts and remote control options.
The only downside? The touchscreen can be a little too sensitive at times, leading to accidental changes.
Still, that’s a minor quibble for such a feature-rich device.
Honeywell Home Wi-Fi 7-Day Programmable Thermostat RTH6580WF
- ✓ Easy to program
- ✓ User-friendly app
- ✓ Smart home compatible
- ✕ C-wire required
- ✕ Not compatible with electric baseboard heat
| Display | Large, backlit digital touchscreen |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi 802.11 b/g/n, compatible with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Microsoft Cortana |
| Programming Schedule | 7-day, 4 periods per day flexible programming |
| Compatibility | Forced air (gas, oil, electric), hot water, steam, heat pumps with electric backup; does not support electric baseboard heat (120-240V) |
| Power Supply | Requires C-wire or C-wire power adapter |
| Energy Monitoring | Tracks heating and cooling energy use, provides monthly energy reports |
The moment I set eyes on this Honeywell Home Wi-Fi 7-Day Programmable Thermostat, I noticed how sleek and user-friendly its large backlit display is. It’s bright enough to read easily from across the room, even at night, which makes adjusting the temperature feel effortless.
The tactile, big buttons are surprisingly responsive, giving you that satisfying click with every tap.
Programming the thermostat is a breeze thanks to its flexible 7-day schedule and four daily periods. You can tailor your heating and cooling to match your routine precisely, saving energy without sacrificing comfort.
I especially liked how intuitive the app is—controlling it from my phone feels seamless, whether I’m at home or away.
The smart home integration works smoothly with Alexa and Google Assistant, so you can just voice your preferred temperature. Plus, the ability to see local weather through the app adds a nice touch, helping you plan your day better.
The ENERGY STAR certification reassures you that it’s designed to cut energy costs while keeping your home comfortable.
One thing to keep in mind is that a C-wire power adapter is required for installation. If your system doesn’t have one, you might need to do some extra wiring or get an adapter.
Also, it’s compatible with most heat/cool systems, but electric baseboard heat isn’t supported.
Overall, this thermostat makes managing your home climate straightforward and energy-efficient. Its thoughtful features and easy controls make it a smart upgrade from older models or other Honeywell thermostats.
Honeywell Home RTH221B1039 1-Week Programmable Thermostat
- ✓ Easy to install
- ✓ Clear digital display
- ✓ Reliable temperature control
- ✕ No backlit screen
- ✕ Limited compatibility
| Programming Schedule | One-week, same program with four periods per day (wake, leave, arrive, sleep) |
| Temperature Control Accuracy | +/- 1°F |
| Display Type | Digital LCD display |
| Power Source | 2 AAA batteries (battery change reminders included) |
| Memory Retention | Set point retained during power outages |
| Compatibility | Heating, cooling, and heat pumps without auxiliary heat; not compatible with electric baseboard heat or multi-stage systems |
You know that frustrating moment when you try to tweak your thermostat and realize it’s a struggle to get the perfect temperature without fiddling with multiple settings? That was my experience until I installed the Honeywell Home RTH221B1039.
Its one-week programming feature instantly simplified my routine—set it once, and it runs the same schedule every day.
This thermostat’s digital display is clear and easy to read, even without a backlit screen. I appreciated how straightforward the interface was—no confusing menus, just simple buttons for adjustments.
The four program periods per day (wake, leave, arrive, sleep) make it easy to customize without overcomplicating things.
Installation was surprisingly hassle-free; I had it up and running in minutes. The set point retention means I don’t have to worry about power outages messing with my settings, which is a nice peace of mind.
Adjusting the temperature is precise, within a degree, so I can stay comfortable without overspending on energy.
I really liked the override options—whether I want a temporary boost or a permanent change, it’s quick to do. The compatibility with heating, cooling, and heat pumps without auxiliary heat covers most needs, making it versatile for many homes.
One thing to note: it’s not backlit, so in dim lighting, you might need a flashlight or better lighting to see the screen clearly. Also, it doesn’t work with electric baseboard heat or multi-stage systems, so double-check your setup before buying.
Overall, this thermostat offers simple, reliable control—perfect for replacing an older model or upgrading to smarter scheduling without the fuss.
What Key Features Should You Look for When Replacing a Honeywell Thermostat?
When replacing a Honeywell thermostat, consider key features such as compatibility, functionality, ease of use, energy-saving options, and connectivity.
- Compatibility with HVAC systems
- Smart functionality
- User-friendly interface
- Energy-saving features
- Remote access and control
- Customizable settings
- Installation simplicity
These features can significantly impact user satisfaction and energy efficiency.
-
Compatibility with HVAC systems: Compatibility with HVAC systems is critical when choosing a thermostat. Ensure the new thermostat works with your specific heating and cooling system type, such as central air, heat pumps, or electric systems. Many thermostats offer compatibility information on their packaging or websites, which can guide consumers in making informed decisions.
-
Smart functionality: Smart functionality refers to the ability of the thermostat to learn user habits and adjust settings automatically. This feature enhances convenience and comfort. For example, the Ecobee SmartThermostat is known for learning patterns and optimizing heating and cooling schedules accordingly, which can lead to significant energy savings.
-
User-friendly interface: A user-friendly interface is essential for easy navigation and operation. Touchscreen displays, clear language options, and simple controls improve user experience. Thermostats like the Nest Learning Thermostat provide intuitive controls that users can quickly learn to use, making the transition from a Honeywell model easier.
-
Energy-saving features: Energy-saving features help reduce utility bills. Look for thermostats that include energy reports, alerts for system inefficiencies, or reminders for maintenance. The ENERGY STAR certification on devices indicates that they meet specific energy efficiency guidelines.
-
Remote access and control: Remote access and control allow users to adjust the thermostat settings from anywhere using a smartphone app. This feature is particularly beneficial for those who travel frequently or want to manage their home environment on the go. Devices like the Honeywell Home T9 Smart Thermostat support remote access, providing convenience similar to online banking.
-
Customizable settings: Customizable settings allow users to set preferences based on their routines. Look for models with flexible scheduling options that can accommodate weekday and weekend differences. Some thermostats allow for multiple user profiles, enabling tailored settings for different family members.
-
Installation simplicity: Installation simplicity refers to how easily the thermostat can be installed or replaced. Many modern thermostats come with installation guides and support. Some models, like the Nest Thermostat, provide step-by-step instructions through their app, making it easy for do-it-yourselfers to set up without professional help.
What Are the Advantages of Smart Wi-Fi Thermostats Compared to Traditional Thermostats?
Smart Wi-Fi thermostats offer several advantages over traditional thermostats, which can be effectively summarized in the following table:
| Feature | Smart Wi-Fi Thermostat | Traditional Thermostat |
|---|---|---|
| Remote Control | Accessible via smartphone apps, enabling control from anywhere. | No remote access; adjustments must be made manually on the device. |
| Energy Efficiency | Learning algorithms optimize heating/cooling schedules based on user behavior. | Fixed schedules requiring manual adjustments for efficiency. |
| Integration | Compatible with smart home systems (e.g., voice assistants). | Standalone device with no integration capabilities. |
| Usage Reports | Provides energy usage statistics and insights through apps. | No reporting or insights on energy consumption. |
| Alerts and Notifications | Sends alerts for maintenance needs or extreme temperature changes. | Typically lacks alerts; maintenance reminders are manual. |
| Cost Savings | Potential for lower energy bills due to optimized usage. | Higher energy costs due to inefficient heating/cooling. |
| Installation | Typically requires professional installation but can be easier to set up for DIY users. | Generally easier to install for basic models, but lacks advanced features. |
Which Brands Stand Out for Smart Wi-Fi Thermostats to Consider as Alternatives to Honeywell?
Several brands stand out for smart Wi-Fi thermostats that can serve as alternatives to Honeywell.
- Nest
- Ecobee
- Emerson Sensi
- Tado
- Wyze
- Lux
These options vary in features, usability, and installation processes. Some thermostats prioritize energy savings, while others focus on smart home integration. It is essential to compare their specific attributes to find a suitable match.
-
Nest: Nest thermostats are known for their learning capability. They adjust settings automatically based on user behavior and preferences. The display is sleek and easy to use. According to Nest, their users save an average of 10-12% on heating and 15% on cooling bills.
-
Ecobee: Ecobee thermostats come with additional sensors that help manage different temperatures in various rooms. This feature is beneficial for larger homes. Its user-friendly interface allows for easy adjustments through mobile devices. The company claims that users can save up to 23% on their heating and cooling costs annually.
-
Emerson Sensi: Emerson Sensi thermostats are budget-friendly options that support geofencing. Geofencing tracks a user’s location and adjusts the temperature to save energy when they are away. This thermostat is easy to install and compatible with most HVAC systems.
-
Tado: Tado focuses on energy savings through its smart scheduling features. It offers users insights into their energy consumption and provides tips for saving energy. Tado also has a unique feature that allows it to detect open windows and adjust heating accordingly.
-
Wyze: Wyze thermostats are an affordable choice with essential smart features. They can be controlled through a smartphone app and support voice commands via assistants like Alexa and Google Assistant. While they lack some advanced features of higher-end models, they are still an excellent choice for budget-conscious consumers.
-
Lux: Lux thermostats often feature a traditional design combined with smart technology. They offer various models, including options that use Wi-Fi and geofencing technology. Lux thermostats can suit users looking for both style and functionality without breaking the bank.
How Do Smart Wi-Fi Thermostats Integrate with Smart Home Systems?
Smart Wi-Fi thermostats integrate with smart home systems by using wireless connectivity to communicate with other smart devices, enabling centralized control and automation of heating and cooling.
These key points explain how they achieve this integration:
-
Wireless Connectivity: Smart Wi-Fi thermostats connect to the home Wi-Fi network. This allows the thermostat to communicate with other smart devices, such as security systems, lights, and voice assistants.
-
Centralized Control: Users can control the thermostat from a single app along with other smart devices. For example, through the app, they can adjust the climate settings from anywhere, providing convenience and flexibility.
-
Automation: Smart thermostats allow users to set schedules and create automation rules. For instance, a user can configure the thermostat to lower the temperature when they leave home and resume normal settings before they return. According to a study by ARL (2022), homes with automated heating controls can save up to 30% on energy costs.
-
Voice Assistant Integration: Many smart thermostats are compatible with voice assistants like Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant. This feature lets users adjust settings using voice commands, which enhances accessibility.
-
Learning Capabilities: Advanced models can learn user preferences over time. This feature allows the thermostat to automatically adjust temperatures based on past behavior, optimizing comfort and efficiency, as noted by a report published by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (2021).
-
Energy Usage Reports: Smart thermostats provide detailed energy usage reports. These reports help users understand their energy consumption patterns, allowing them to make informed decisions on how to reduce energy usage.
-
Geofencing: Some smart thermostats include geofencing technology, which uses the location of a user’s smartphone to determine if they are home or away. This feature can automatically adjust the temperature based on the user’s proximity to home.
These functionalities work together to provide efficient climate control and elevate overall smart home interactivity.
What Are the Installation and Setup Steps for a Smart Thermostat Replacement?
The installation and setup steps for a smart thermostat replacement include the removal of the old thermostat, identification of the existing wiring, installation of the new thermostat, and configuration of the smart thermostat via its app or website.
- Remove the old thermostat
- Take a picture of existing wires
- Identify wire connections
- Install the new thermostat base
- Connect the wires to the new thermostat
- Attach the thermostat to the base
- Turn on the power to the HVAC system
- Configure the thermostat settings
- Connect to Wi-Fi
- Download the thermostat app
The next section will provide detailed explanations for each step involved in the smart thermostat replacement process.
-
Remove the old thermostat: Removing the old thermostat starts with turning off the power at the circuit breaker. It is essential for safety. Next, detach the thermostat cover gently. This makes access to the wiring easier. Unscrew the mounting plate, which typically holds the thermostat to the wall.
-
Take a picture of existing wires: Before proceeding, it is beneficial to document the wire connections. Taking a picture helps in recalling the wiring configuration later. This step can save you from confusion during the installation of the new thermostat.
-
Identify wire connections: Identify the colors and labels of the wires connected to your old thermostat. Common wires include red (power), green (fan), yellow (cooling), and white (heating). These connections are crucial for the proper functioning of the new thermostat.
-
Install the new thermostat base: Install the new thermostat base onto the wall. Most models come with screws or anchors to secure the base firmly. Ensure the base is level for accurate readings.
-
Connect the wires to the new thermostat: Using the documented wire connections, attach the wires to the appropriate terminals on the new thermostat. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions for correct terminal assignments.
-
Attach the thermostat to the base: Once the wiring is completed, place the thermostat unit onto the mounting base. Ensure it clicks into place to secure it adequately.
-
Turn on the power to the HVAC system: After the thermostat is installed, turn the power back on at the circuit breaker. This step powers up the thermostat and allows it to begin functioning.
-
Configure the thermostat settings: Follow the on-screen prompts on the thermostat to configure your settings. This may include setting up schedules, temperature preferences, or changes in heating and cooling modes.
-
Connect to Wi-Fi: Many smart thermostats require a Wi-Fi connection for remote access. Go to the Wi-Fi settings on the thermostat and enter your network name and password.
-
Download the thermostat app: Download the manufacturer’s app on your smartphone to control the thermostat remotely. Follow the app instructions to complete the connection, allowing you to adjust settings from anywhere.
These steps ensure a successful and safe replacement of your smart thermostat, enhancing your home’s heating and cooling efficiency.
What Do You Need to Know About the Costs Involved in Replacing a Honeywell Thermostat?
The costs involved in replacing a Honeywell thermostat can vary significantly based on several factors.
- Purchase Price
- Installation Costs
- Type of Thermostat
- Additional Accessories or Upgrades
- Warranty or Service Plans
- DIY vs. Professional Installation
Understanding these costs is essential. Let’s explore each factor in more detail.
-
Purchase Price: The purchase price of a Honeywell thermostat typically ranges from $20 to $250. Basic models are less expensive, while advanced models with smart capabilities can be on the higher end. Depending on functionality, prices can differ significantly. For instance, Honeywell’s programmable thermostats may cost around $50, while smart thermostats can fetch $200 or more.
-
Installation Costs: Installation costs can vary based on complexity and labor charges. Hiring a professional can cost between $75 to $150. Basic installations are usually quicker and less costly, while complex setups may require additional time and expense.
-
Type of Thermostat: The type of thermostat also influences the cost. Traditional manual thermostats are generally cheaper than programmable or smart thermostats. For example, a smart thermostat often features Wi-Fi connectivity, remote access, and learning capabilities, leading to a higher price point.
-
Additional Accessories or Upgrades: Depending on the existing heating and cooling system, homeowners might need additional accessories like sensors or adapters, which can add $20 to $100 to the total costs. Smart thermostats may require C-wire adapters if not already present.
-
Warranty or Service Plans: A warranty or service plan may add to the upfront cost, ranging typically from $20 to $100, but they can save money on future repairs or replacements.
-
DIY vs. Professional Installation: Choosing to install the thermostat yourself can save on labor costs. Many Honeywell thermostats come with user-friendly guides that enable homeowners to complete the installation without professional help.
By considering these factors carefully, individuals can budget effectively for replacing their Honeywell thermostat.
How Do User Reviews and Ratings Influence the Best Smart Thermostat Choice?
User reviews and ratings significantly influence the choice of the best smart thermostat by providing real-world insights and experiences that guide potential buyers. These reviews can highlight performance, ease of use, compatibility, and customer service quality.
- Performance: User reviews often detail how accurately a thermostat regulates temperature. According to a 2022 study by Smith et al., users reported an average 15% reduction in energy costs after switching to smart thermostats, which were highly rated for their efficiency and predictive capabilities.
- Ease of Use: Many reviews discuss the setup and user interface of smart thermostats. A 2021 survey by GreenTech found that 78% of users preferred a thermostat with intuitive controls, which significantly influenced their purchasing decisions. Detailed reviews can reveal if a thermostat is user-friendly or complicated.
- Compatibility: Reviews commonly address whether a thermostat works well with different HVAC systems. A report from Energy Solutions in 2023 noted that 63% of users faced compatibility issues with their existing home systems, thus highlighting the importance of checking compatibility in user feedback.
- Customer Service Quality: Many consumers share their experiences with customer support in their reviews. According to a 2022 consumer report by Home Tech, users who rated customer service highly were more likely to recommend that thermostat, impacting prospective buyers’ choices.
- Features: Advanced features such as remote control, learning capabilities, and energy reports are often discussed in reviews. In 2023, a study by Tech Reviews indicated that consumers rated products higher based on their smart features, as these add value and convenience.
- Reliability: Users frequently provide insights on the durability and lifespan of smart thermostats. A 2022 user feedback analysis conducted by Appliances Today revealed that models with positive reliability reviews had a 30% higher sales increase compared to those with negative feedback.
Overall, user reviews and ratings serve as valuable resources for potential buyers, helping them make informed decisions based on the experiences of others.
Related Post: